Jan Cornell has a weekly radio show called The Crime Was Never Solved in which she dramatizes, well, unsolved crimes. The voice and sound effects cast includes her friend and roommate Smitty, and the show's sponsor is Stanley Cigarettes, in the person of A.J. Stanley and his wife Eve. Her show competes with a crime show hosted by Michael Jerome, and his show is gaining on hers in the ratings so Jan announces that her next show will be about the unsolved murder of actress Lenore Fenwick and that she will solve the case. Fenwick was found dead in a cabin on the grounds of the Crying Pines Lodge with the pages of her unfinished memoir next to her. Her producer is not happy with this development but A.J. encourages her in order to show up Michael, though Stanley's wife is not so happy. Neither is cast member Mida Kent who gives a lame excuse for not being present for the next show. Mida calls Jan later that night and asks to meet with her, but she is murdered before she can talk. Newspaper columnist Bill Burton brings Michael into the group and soon he is helping Jan investigate, and of course striking small romantic sparks with her. It turns out that Mida was present at Crying Pines the night of Lenore's death night, as was secretary Irene Hill who has gone missing. When Jan and Smitty go to the cabin to record the sound of the "crying pines," they are threatened by a mystery woman who is herself shot and killed. That woman was Eve Stanley, who was originally Irene Hill. Stanley claims to have known nothing about his wife's past, but more digging by Jan and Smitty and Michael bring stolen money and a blackmail attempt to light and Jan is able to solve the case just moments before the climax of her radio show, which she is then able to retitle The Crime That WAS Solved.
This is a fairly fun hour-long B-mystery from Republic which remains light on its feet, in both tone and pacing. Ruth Terry (Jan) is only OK in the main role, outshone by Mary Treen as Smitty; nowadays, Smitty would be the lesbian best friend but here she's just an unsophisticated working girl. Frank Albertson (Michael) is good but unfairly top-billed; he and Terry do work up some chemistry, but to the movie's credit, she remains the primary sleuth while he mostly waits in the background for the right moment for a kiss (which, in the last scene, is comically timed at a full minute by the radio show staff). Nils Asther has a small role as (what else?) an exotic gigolo type and Wynne Gibson is fine as Eve Stanley. Francis Pierlot plays the eccentric Mr. Crunch, supervisor of a newspaper morgue (yes, a misunderstanding of that word pops up for comedy). Charles Hayes and Kirk Alyn show up in bit parts as handsome policemen whom Smitty flirts with. Addison Richards does what he can with the ill-defined role of Bill Burton. The nighttime scene at Crying Pines is nicely atmospheric, and the whole thing goes down pleasantly. Pictured are Albertson and Terry. [Streaming]












