John Herford is on trial in London for sending letters threatening to kill a man with a rope, then following through. The press gives him the nickname The Laughing Murderer because of, well, his constant laughter when asked questions. One woman on the jury holds out for a verdict of insanity, but eventually she joins the other jurors in finding him guilty and he's executed by hanging. Months later, a barber named Smith, who was the killer's hangman, gets a letter threatening death, with a piece of rope enclosed. He doesn't give it much thought, but he is attacked and nearly killed with a rope. Crime writer Alastair Dane (Wilfrid Hyde-White), who wrote a book about the Laughing Murderer, goes to see Inspector Walker who says the handwritten notes (a warning was also received by Scotland Yard) seem to be in the same handwriting as the dead killer and he calls in a handwriting expert named Hanson to study the letters. A few nights later, Dane attends a weekend party at the country house of Mrs. Mulcaire. Also attending is Sir Henry Paxton, the judge in the Herford case, who has recently received a threatening letter with a chunk of rope, though he also seems unconcerned. Others at the house party include Sir Henry's nephew Peter, his girlfriend Daphne, and actress Lucille Davine. Peter is seeking money from his uncle to stop a scandal of some sort from coming out. There is also a suspicious butler named Simpson whom Flora the maid seems secretly close to. Hanson shows up to examine the latest letter that Sir Henry got. Dane talks everyone into participating in a parlor game of sorts in which he will stage the murder scene from a play he's working on, and hopes to get Lucille to act in. Suddenly, the lights go out, Mrs. Mulcaire's necklace is stolen, and Sir Henry is discovered dead, strangled with a rope. The phone lines have been cut and the cars all tampered with, and since no contact with the police is possible, Dane and Hanson are left to investigate.
At heart, this is a fairly traditional single-setting mystery but with some unusual touches. If you're the kind of viewer who thinks mysteries should be "fair" and that we should be able to figure things out based on clues presented, you won't like this. The solution is satisfying but can't really be deduced from the information we have. Much of the information that we do get is incomplete or confusing or turns out to be a red herring—for example, the theft of the necklace and the relationship of Simpson and Flora, which both feel extraneous to the narrative. The first five minutes in the jury room has absolutely nothing to do with the rest of the story except to briefly give the movie another setting aside from the country house. The house itself is a low-budget version of a country house, and the cast, for the most part, seem to have been hired for their looks as actresses or sniveling nephews or gigolos (Sylvester, a character who has almost nothing to do but look like a gigolo). Future supporting actor star Wilfrid Hyde-White is fine as Dane but his performance seems a little underdone. Standouts in the cast, though their careers went nowhere, are Sunday Wilshin (Lucille, top right), Guy Belmore (Simpson), and Donald Read (Peter, at left). An exchange that felt forced but still made me chuckle: Sir Henry is told that Lucille has "thousands of fans" and he replies, "Does she feel the heat so terribly?" At an hour, it still feels a little bit long but I found the ending worth hanging around for. [YouTube]

















