Under the opening credits, we see the torsos of two nearly naked people as they make out very slowly in a bedroom. A little girl carrying a teddy bear looks in from the hallway, is shocked at what she sees, and runs and trips down the stairs, her bear being torn in two in the process. Next disjointed scene: a man in underwear wakes up, a pornographic novel next to him. As he caresses his body, he makes the latest in a series of obscene phone calls to Norah (Juliet Prowse), a young woman who works as a discotheque DJ in Times Square; she hangs up on him. At the small and sparsely decorated club (it looks more like a good-sized suburban living room) we meet her butch lesbian boss Marian (Elaine Stritch), Carlo, a beefy mute bouncer (Daniel J. Travanti), and a young waiter named Larry (Sal Mineo, at right). We see a drunk try to assault Norah get tossed out by Carlo, though he winds up with some knife wounds. This sets up, or adds to, an aura of potential sexual violence, added to even more when Norah calls the cops about the phone caller. Lt. Dave Madden (Jan Murray), whose wife was raped and killed, has focused unhealthily on sex crimes and, despite the presence of his young daughter in his small apartment, spends evenings listening over and over to tapes of police interviews of sex criminals. For a while, we're not sure who the caller is—even the overly intense Madden is a plausible suspect—but when Norah finds a decapitated teddy bear in her apartment one night, we learn that the caller, and the guy in the opening two scenes, is Larry. With both of his parents dead, he is the sole support of his sister, emotionally and psychologically stunted due to witnessing her brother having sex. Norah likes Larry who seems sweet and innocent, though we see him spending many nighttime hours trawling Times Square porn shops and getting upset when his sister Edie starts dressing, as he sees it, like a whore. After the teddy bear incident, Marian offers to stay with Norah, but when Norah mistakes a calming hug for a pass, Marian leaves and is strangled to death on the street by Larry, who thinks she's Norah. The climax involves a rape, a nighttime street chase, and a death.
Most reviewers point out the lurid tone of this movie, and it is true that one might feel the need for a shower after watching this. But for me, the thing that stands out most is how much time is spent with the camera focused on Sal Mineo's body. The objectification of the female body, the basis of film studies theories of the "male gaze," is baked into the classic Hollywood movie formula, but here the male gaze is aimed at a man. In real life Mineo was a relatively open bisexual and something of a gay icon, but his character here is not presented as gay. Perhaps the director, Joseph Cates (father of Phoebe Cates), assumed that the novelty of seeing a man in tight white underwear, and an even tighter speedo in a pool scene, would help the movie stand out. Even today, a scene with Mineo, in his underwear, masturbating by grinding against a mattress, is a bit shocking. The psychological underpinnings of the movie seem suspect. There is no examination of the trauma suffered by Larry and Edie. It didn't make sense to me that Larry kills Marian when he thinks she is Norah, but doesn't try to kill Norah later when he has the chance. But this is basically pulp fiction, not a realistic case study.
Mineo is very good, convincing both as a sweet buddy to Norah and as a perverted stalker. Prowse and Stritch are equally fine, and though I had my doubts at first about Borscht Belt comic Jan Murray in a straight role, he's OK, though at times I felt as if he was just dying to bust out with a Jewish mother joke or two. Margot Bennett (Edie) was married at the time to Keir Dullea and later married Malcolm McDowell. Daniel J. Travanti (above left) is surprisingly handsome and effective in his small role. There are several location shots of Manhattan streets, the Central Park zoo, and the tawdry Times Square neighborhood that are historically interesting. There isn't much humor here, but I chuckled at a shot of a porn store window which pans across three titles: Sex Crimes in History, Fanny Hill, and a Webster's dictionary. This has the look and feel of a fairly cheap but arty grindhouse movie, but with A-ish level actors—Mineo was an Oscar nominee and Stritch later won Emmys and a Tony. Most reviews use words like lurid, unsavory, sweaty, perverted and kinky, and they all fit, but it’s also interesting and kinkily entertaining. [TCM]
















