On a rural estate in 19th century Paris, two children, Mimsey and Gogo, are arguing from their adjacent yards about sharing pieces of wood; she's making a dollhouse and he's repairing a wagon. Beneath the arguing, however, the two actually share a strong bond of togetherness. Gogo is considered by the adults to be a strange, overly sensitive child, and when his mother dies, his uncle takes him away to England, changing his name to Peter, and he and Mimsey suffer through a traumatic parting. Years later, Peter is a successful young architect; his buddies like to relax by going out on the town for "gin, bitters and barmaids," but Peter, though well liked, is still considered a little strange and doesn't share their enthusiasms. His boss, fearing Peter is suffering from overwork, sends him on a vacation to Paris. He is flirted with by goodtime girl Agnes, but has more interest in seeing his old home which sparks vague childhood memories. Later, on a visit to Yorkshire to work on some horse stable remodeling for the Duke of Towers, he is vetted by Mary, the Duchess; they clash on ideas for the project (she wants new, modern designs, and he wants the stables to retain an antique feeling), and he threatens to turn down the job. But a spark is starting to catch between them and she gives into his wishes. While living at the estate as he works, he becomes even closer to Mary, and one night they both have the same dream about a storm. Before long, they realize that Peter was Gogo and Mary was Mimsey, and not only are they in love with each other but that they share, through their dreams, a possibly supernatural link. The Duke figures things out and threatens Peter with a gun; during a scuffle, Peter kills the Duke and is sentenced to life in prison. Emaciated and in tatters, Peter gets in a fight with a guard; his back is broken and he is expected to die soon. But Mary visits him in his dreams and assures him that they can live together happily in this dream world. They do for years, meeting in idyllic settings, both looking young and healthy even as they both age in real life. They reach the end of their lives at the same time, and Mary tells him they will be together even in death.
I first encountered this fantasy many years ago in the first blush of my love affair with classic films. It had a solid reputation with some critics as an example of accessible surrealism, an expression of the unconscious with little regard for rationality, with emotion trumping logic. I don't see what I think of as surreal elements in this movie (I'm thinking imagery from Dali or Magritte), but it certainly has a delicate otherworldly tone right from the beginning, and emotion certainly wins out over logic. The cinematography by Charles Lang, especially in the last half-hour, is dreamy and gorgeous even in the scenes depicting Peter languishing in prison. I watched it again a few years later and was less taken by it. But with this viewing, I have settled on liking it quite a bit, for various reasons. As a supernatural romantic fantasy, it's just as good if not better than films like Portrait of Jennie, The Ghost and Mrs. Muir, A Guy Named Joe, or Somewhere in Time. Gary Cooper (above right) gives a performance unlike any of his others. He is very handsome, as he was in his early films. Later he was known for his down-to-earth performances, but here he is very gentle, intelligent, expressive and emotional without getting sentimental or overwrought. He almost disappears into his part, something you can't say about him in his later roles. Ann Harding, as Mary (pictured with Cooper at left), matches him quite well, loosening out of the boring routine of her life with the Duke to the lush tenderness of what becomes her dream self. As I've noted, the movie's visuals are beautiful from beginning to end; there's an almost ghostly glow to most everything, even people's faces. You may fight the fantastical elements of the narrative, but most viewers will probably give in to the pull of the illogical and emotional. Supporting actors of note include Donald Meek as Peter's boss, a blind man who perhaps can see some things better than Peter can; Ida Lupino as Agnes; John Halliday as the Duke, who remains somewhat sympathetic; Virginia Weidler and Dickie Moore as the the young Mimsey and Gogo. You may spot Harry Cording and Leonid Kinsey in small roles in the prison scenes. The effect of Mary's first visit to Peter, as her dream self slips through the prison bars, is very effective. The idea that a pre-adolescent attraction that was forgotten about for many years could retain such power over reality doesn't bear a lot of thought. Directed by Henry Hathaway, better known for adventure and crime films. Worth seeing, if only as a novelty. [DVD]















