Friday, November 20, 2026

ISLE OF FORGOTTEN SINS (1943)

Mike and Jack are two competitive pearl divers on a South Seas island. We would probably call them frenemies. While Mike was passed out drunk, Jack tied him to his bed, stole his money and headed off to the Isle of Forgotten Sins, a combination bar, casino and brothel, and tells Marge, the madam, that Mike, her lover, is dead, but when Mike struts in, the two engage in an epic fistfight that ranges over both floors of the building. Carruthers, the head of a nearby island plantation, stops the fight. The two are currently searching for the Tropic Star, a ship that disappeared months ago and supposedly went down somewhere in the area with three million dollars in gold on board. It turns out that Carruthers is actually Krogan, the captain of the ship; the Tropic Star is underwater near the coast of his private island and he needs help to bring the gold up. When one of the hookers shoots and kills an abusive man, Marge and all her girls take refuge on Jack and Mike’s boat and they all head to Krogan’s island. Krogan deliberately leaves out pages from the Tropic Star's log book for the two men to find and they go off to salvage the gold. His plan is to take the gold from them and split it with his pianist buddy and former ship mate Johnny. But things don't go as planned, and when a monsoon hits the island, all bets are off. The king of classic-era B movies, Edgar G. Ulmer, directed this, though there's little that's distinctive about it. The cast is a bit unusual. John Carradine, who is top billed, plays a rare good guy lead as Mike and is surprisingly energetic, and Frank Fenton, mostly known for character parts in westerns, is Jack. The two don't really work up much chemistry and I had a hard time caring what happened to them, a fault of both the acting and the lackadaisical writing. Gale Sondergaard is Marge and though she gets a fair amount of screen time, she has little to do except for anchoring piddly little side plots involving two of the Sins workers (the bad girl Veda Ann Borg and the good girl Rita Quigley). Most interesting is Sidney Toler, best known as the lead in over 20 Charlie Chan movies, as Krogan. He’s not bad but even he seems to be a bit tamped down, giving a rather mild performance as a villain. Rick Vallin gives some life to his role as Johnny. The concept of the Isle of Forgotten Sins had potential but it's almost totally ignored. The final storm scene is OK but too little too late to salvage the movie. Slow and drab, not up to Ulmer's usual standards. Pictured are Vallin, Toler, and Borg. [YouTube]

No comments: